Select Page


va ptsd disability

I read a post online the other day from another Veteran who felt compelled to perpetuate a few myths about PTSD.

We are going to break those myths wide open, below.

But first, here’s his full quote from Google+:

“If you had ptsd when u were discharged u should not have to worry… your medical records would show it and if it doesn’t then u obviously don’t have service connected PTSD, this … is a fakers way to keep the VA backlog huge and screw over those of us who really need it…

…It took me five years of fighting with the VA mostly due to the fact that soldiers who didn’t do shit but want to get paid and it is disgusting and implorable in every sense of the word… And I am an 11B and I have 80% service connected w/ PTSD and other injuries. And all I needed was my medical records.  Don’t be a mooching faker.”

How would you respond to a post like this?

I don’t believe in putting someone down for being wrong, and its much easier to fix “bad information” – all we have to do is supply good information:  education and information are truly the source of power.

I’d really love to sit this young man and have him explain his “you can’t be diagnosed with PTSD years later” theory to the wives of the dozens of Vietnam Veterans that I have represented.

I’d love to show him PTSD through their eyes – 2o or 30 years or more of avoidance behaviors, anger, abuse of alcohol/drugs, etc.

Do you think face-to-face education like that  would do the trick?

Maybe. Maybe not.

Either way, let’s tackle 5 Myths about Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (aka, PTSD or PTS).

Myth #1.  You’re a mooching faker if PTSD is not diagnosed while you are in the service.

I don’t really know what a “mooching faker” is.

But I think that anyone who implies that a Veteran is lying because his/her PTSD was diagnosed years – or decades – after the traumatic event is about as full of s**t as they come.

PTSD is often a latent condition. What does that mean? A latent condition is one that may or may not appear until many years after a traumatic event.

Many times, to continue to function in battle, soldier sailor or airman will suppress memories of a certain incident.   They might mentally tell themselves: “I have to stay alive, I will deal with this later.”

Some don’t deal with it later. Some self-medicate with drugs or alcohol.

Some veterans may be in denial about the possibility that they might have PTSD – thanks in large part to the nonsense spread by other soldiers.

Regardless of the cause, PTSD is often not diagnosed for years – sometimes  decades – after the traumatic condition.

I know a Vietnam era Veteran whose first exposure to combat as an 18 year old kid was a game of hot-potato with the severed hand of a Vietcong prisoner.  He pushed that event – and the subsequent year of hostility – deep into his subconscious.

When he returned from Vietnam, he spent 20 years rambling around the country, shooting up heroin and trying to avoid dealing with what he saw. Fortunately, he cleaned up, and is doing very well – but only because of  a diagnosis of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, group therapy through the VA (and other places), and the support of his family and friends.

Unfortunately, even people with large audiences spread such myths.

I recently heard a podcast where renowned 4-Hour Workweek Guru Tim Ferris interviewed Restrepo author Sebastian Junger.

In an otherwise exceptional and gripping interview, Sebastian Junger (director of the military documentary Restrepo) went off on a tangent – under the guise of a journalist reporting “facts” – and proceeded to accuse some Veterans with PTSD of dishonesty, cheating the system because the VA let them “self-diagnose” with PTSD just to get a disability check.

(I’m paraphrasing – take a listen to the podcast yourself, the offensive and flat out untruthful part begins at Minute 107)

If someone tells you that you are a “mooching faker” because you were diagnosed with PTSD years, or decades, after service, or because you didn’t have to prove your medical condition to the VA, tell them to call me.

I’d be happy to set them straight. That includes you, Mr. Junger.

By the way, to counter all the nonsense that is out there for Veterans, here is a great place to start walking  through the 4 Focus Areas of a VA PTSD Disability claim or appeal.

You’ll also want to learn my 8 Steps to improving your VA Claim or Appeal .


Myth #2: People with PTSD are crazy people.

A diagnosis of PTSD does not mean that a person is insane crazy or a lunatic. This is part of the overall social stigma of mental health.

People that are diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder have a number of different symptoms – they manifest in different ways for each and every person.

I think that the reason people think the PTSD victim is  “crazy” is because the behaviors that protect the person are as extraordinary as the trauma that caused them.

PTSD Symptoms fall into 3 categories:

Category 1: Reliving the Trauma (flashbacks, racing heart, sweating, bad dreams, frightening thoughts). This will cause problems in the everyday life of the trauma victim.  Words, objects, situations, smells, sounds – or inexplicable sensations – can trigger the “reliving experience”. It can paralyze the victim.

Category 2: Avoidance Symptoms (avoiding the people, places and things that serve as a reminder of the experience, emotional numbness, strong guilt, depression, worry, loss of interest in previously enjoyable activities, memory problems).  I know one soldier that suffers from PTSD – he never leaves his house.  He’s too scared that something out there may trigger a flashback and cause him to hurt someone else.

Category 3: Hyper-arousal or Hyper-vigilance (easily startled, tenseness, edginess, angry outbursts, over-protective measures, difficulty sleeping).  The sense of “hyper-vigilance” – overprotectiveness of possessions and people – is a hallmark symptom of PTSD.

Myth #3: If you were mentally Tougher you would not get PTSD.

This one drives me batty, every time I hear it.

Disappointingly, I hear it most often from  members of the Special Operations community – a study that suggests that special operations soldiers are “hyper-resilient” to stress has been twisted into the belief that operators are immune to PTSD.

Resilience is not the same as resistance.

It is true that  training “steels” them to deal with much more than your average soldier, sailor or airmen.  But they also have much more gruesome experiences than the average soldier, sailor or airmen.

We can all help debunk this particular myth by making sure that others know that it is acceptable and right to get help if you are suffering from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. 

If 13 years of war does one good thing, I hope it is that it removes the stigma associated with mental health treatment – forever.

What do you think causes Veterans to believe that PTSD is the result of not being mentally tough?

Myth #4: If you were not in combat you can’t get PTSD.

Post Traumatic Stress Disorder is not a condition unique to combat veterans.

Any number of incidents can cause PTSD.

I represent one Veteran who has PTSD from an incident when she was stationed overseas and her command wouldn’t let her leave to attend to a custody suit back in the states that her husband had filed.

She lost her children in that custody suit, and was forever traumatized by it.

Read this post to learn other situations which might cause PTSD.

Myth #5: Nobody can help you with your PTSD.

Absolutely not true.

There are certain factors that help folks to cope and live with PTSD.  Some of these factors include:

  • Seeking out support from other people, such as friends and family
  • Finding a support group after a traumatic event
  • Feeling good about one’s own actions in the face of danger
  • Having a coping strategy, or a way of getting through the bad event and learning from it
  • Being able to act and respond effectively despite feeling fear.

Many people cannot get to the place where the believe these so-called “Resilience” factors without help.

But you can’t get help until you ask.

This post isn’t meant to be a resource list, but you should start with the VA – its where you will find other Vets who are dealing with the same things you are getting treatment.

There is a fear that all the VA will do is drug you up to treat your PTSD.

You can refuse medication, and you should get informed consent about medications.  Ask around and see what kind of experience others had with medication.  Talk to your doctor about your concerns.

Ask for other treatment options.

Find a doctor or psychologist or therapist that gets results – not one that you like, or that looks like you, or that talks like you.  One that gets you results.

If you are suicidal, or contemplating suicide, call the VA Hotline.  

It works. If it doesn’t, call the Suicide Prevention Hotline. 

If that doesn’t work, call 911.

Don’t give up until you find the path out of the darkness.


  1. JMGR

    Did I ever thought I was to be diagnose with PTSD? Never! However, as mentioned on the five Myth, mine developed some 20 years later. Yes, I am a Vietnam Era Veteran, also participated on special ops… I though my life was back in motion once I got out the Military after serving 14yrs. 2 of those years served on the National Guard and Reserve on my first brake in service. However, even though the symptoms were there, I was on denial. “I am not crazy” I used to say. I know I am not but, now I realized what I had what is called PTSD!

    DO not be ashamed on it. Recognize it and get help. I still do. Friends, confront it and deal with it. Help is there but, the first “First Aid Kit” starts with you! Also, On the Lady that spoke about being raped, my heart is with you!!! Believe me, a friend of mine while stationed in Germany went thru a similar situation. Worse of all, her perpetrator was a platoon sergeant. So, PTSD is not a myth and it can happened to anyone. PTSD, It doesn’t discriminate!!!

  2. Jason Miller

    Yes, you should be just a little ashamed of yourself fellow 11B. I myself was a special operations soldier, the only thing I know, and knew, was trained to do, hunt and kill. How do I adjust to civilian life now? Any ideas? Yea, not easy brother. Some can make the transition, some can’t. I’ve always had problems trying to do that. No sleep, crying, not being able to socialize, knowing that you can have someone’s vision go completely black while just going to get their mail. Yea, slack off a bit bro….some really need the help, I’m one of them.

    • Chris Attig


      I am sorry that you are struggling.

      Sharing your story helps others change their perspective, and I hope many folks’ perspectives are changed by your words.


  3. Peggy

    Mooching Faker! Whew!

    Those are very strong words.

    I was raped as a private. I suffer tremendous shame, and I kept it hidden for a very long time. This would have dishonored my family and brought them disgrace.

    But “I was asking for it”, “I was dressed provocatively”, “I enjoyed it”, and “it is a hazard of military service”. Oh, yeh, I know the words that minimize my sexual assault.

    Certainly, I assume I am lessor since I was never combat arms, Mr 11B Infantry Soldier.

    The Faking Moocher

    • Chris Attig

      Thanks for sharing, Peggy. Its hard to tell these stories, and hopefully the folks that believe PTSD is a “fake disease” get a wake-up call.



Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.